There Has To Be a Morning After

In my first post I teased (threatened?) that I would write a comparison of tradition in the legal profession to the great film, Fiddler on the Roof. Instead, this go around I’m focusing on a movie from almost the same time period, The Poseidon Adventure.

This disaster movie gem was released just over 50 years ago and I’ve watched it at least once a year since I was about 12 years old. For those who haven’t seen it, on New Years Eve the luxury liner, SS Poseidon, is flipped over by a gigantic wave caused by a tsunami.  Party goers celebrating in the ship’s ballroom are tumbled about and left hanging from the ceiling or crushed under pianos. There is chaos and screaming, yet all the glamorous 70s gowns manage to stay in place. It is perfection.

That scene alone makes the movie (clip below). But what always stuck with me is what happens in the aftermath.

Gene Hackman plays a disillusioned minister who tries in vain to convince the others that their only chance for survival is to leave the safety of the ballroom and climb to the top (former bottom) of the ship. Only ten listen. The rest think he’s crazy to lead them into the unknown danger that might lie ahead when they could remain where they’re at and wait for rescue.

But Mr. Hackman knows the walls of the ship can’t withstand the pressure of the rising water. The bolts will give away and the room will flood. It’s inevitable. As he leads the small group up out of the ballroom, the water begins to rush in. He was right. Those who stay behind perish.

Most of those he leads through the ship still face a terrible end despite his best efforts. As his followers get picked off one by one, some survivors blame Mr. Hackman for the deaths. After the death of his wife, Ernest Borgnine yells:

“You almost suckered me in! I started to believe in your promises! I thought we had a chance! You took from me the only thing I ever loved in the whole world!”

The changes facing the legal profession have often been described as a wave. Nothing new in my analogy there. But I’ve seen a similar reaction to the wave and the attempts to lead the profession out of the rising water. Maybe 10% immediately embrace the unknown and follow the innovators or become innovators themselves. They try new practice methods, like collaborative law or limited scope. They are comfortable with demystifying the law and more simplified, user-friendly processes to assist self represented litigants. Maybe they even see the value in expanding the exemptions to the practice of law or allowing law societies to grant limited licenses to non-lawyers. But even those who initially see that they must leave the ballroom may have their doubts as some ideas fail.

I’ve had a privilege of being involved in the development of several of the above innovations and now in the development legal guided pathways and online dispute resolution systems. Cool stuff indeed but even I have to wonder if in the end I’ll be a Gene Hackman or Ernest Borgnine….

But there has to be a morning after through any upheaval or unknown facing our profession.

Leave a Reply

Comments (

0

)